Adventure Challenge Alternatives: 6 Date Books and Ideas, and Who Each One Is For
The Adventure Challenge has you scratch off 50 blind dates. What it really costs, what reviews say, and 6 Adventure Challenge alternatives, free ones included.
The coin is already in your hand, right above the silver square, and your partner is watching you, half laughing. Neither of you knows yet what's under there (a pie to bake blindfolded, your first date to replay, a night that could end anywhere), but you do know one thing: the second that square is scratched, you've already said yes.
That's the whole idea behind The Adventure Challenge, and it's a sound one. If you're looking for an Adventure Challenge alternative anyway, chances are some detail is holding you back between wanting it and ordering it: the price of the book on top of the price of every date, challenges that sometimes need a babysitter, or the fear of watching it end up in a drawer after three nights. What you're missing isn't a taste for adventure, it's an adventure that makes room for your schedules, your budget, and sometimes the miles between you.
What The Adventure Challenge Gets Right (and What It Really Costs)
Start with what it figured out. The night you open the book, you don't pick a date, you pick a category together, and the coin decides the rest. The brand compares it to scratching a lottery ticket, "but you win every time," and the rule is spelled out on the Couples Edition page: "No take backs! Once it's scratched off, you HAVE to do it." Over each box, a time and money guide helps you decide, icons flag the challenges that call for a particular place or a babysitter, and every page keeps a sticky strip for a Polaroid and some space to write. You don't choose, you scratch, you commit, and you stick the photo in when you get home: by the fiftieth challenge, the book has become your album.
It's more than a clever sales pitch. In 1993, a study followed 53 married couples for ten weeks, an hour and a half together each week: the ones who spent that time on activities they found exciting ended up more satisfied with their marriage than the ones who kept to evenings that were only pleasant. The book manufactures exactly that, novelty nobody had to negotiate, and someone on Reddit puts it better than the product page: "It feels very adventurous to just commit to doing a surprise date."
The real price, next, and it starts at $49.99 for the Couples Edition on the brand's US site. The instant camera isn't included, and the bundle that adds it is $99.99, marked down from $209.99. Then come the evenings themselves: the brand says its 50 challenges range from $0 to $50, sometimes with a market or a body of water to find near you. And if you're reading from Europe, the brand's EU store sells the same book for €29.99.
Read enough Adventure Challenge couples reviews and the same picture comes into focus. The book holds 4.7 out of 5 across more than 6,700 Amazon ratings and 4.71 across 978 reviews on the brand's own site, but 3.4 on Trustpilot, across more than 2,800 reviews, where the frustration is aimed at shipping and customer service far more than at the book. On Reddit, three complaints keep coming back. The cost of the evenings, first: "It's been SO FUN!! But so expensive," writes someone who's "had to buy a couple of things" along the way. The logistics, next: some challenges need a babysitter if you have kids, and the brand itself warns couples outside the US that they'll "definitely see some American culture in the challenges." And the book that quietly falls asleep, last: "we did like 3 of them… never did any again," says another Redditor.
Add to that a shape that runs out: fifty challenges, then a Volume 2 of thirty, and nothing for couples who live far apart. The book is right about what matters most: a date you didn't have to choose has already done half the work. All that's left is finding the shape that will hold up in your own life.
6 Adventure Challenge Alternatives, and Who Each Is For
From the book's closest cousin to what costs nothing at all, each one keeps at least one of its three good ideas: chance, commitment, and the keepsake.
1. Scratch-off date cards, the same surprise for less
The closest to the book's gesture. 35 Scratch Off Date Night Ideas, from All Natural Shop, puts the dates on a deck of cards and keeps the book's rule word for word: once a card is scratched, there are "no take backs." Each card gives a hint of what's waiting, at home or out, and even whether you'll need a sitter. It's $16.95, with 4.5 out of 5 across 8,184 ratings. It's a Date! stretches to 40 cards for $16.99, at 4.6 out of 5 across 5,356 ratings.
If what you want is a real book, with room for the photos, the closest clone is The Date Night Book by Better Bonds: 60 scratch-off dates, sorted into going out and staying in, each with its time and budget guide, and pages to write down what happened. It's $45.99, with 4.7 out of 5 across 348 ratings, and yes, blindfolded baking is in there too.
The right pick if you want the same surprise under the silver for less, or a longer book than the original.
2. 21 Challenges for Two, the evening's draw
The most literal cousin, even if it doesn't fit in your hand. 21 Challenges for Two is the edition Unveil wrote on the same idea as the book: a calendar neither of you has read ahead. Each evening, a square opens on two challenges of different kinds (words, a gesture, an outing), you pick one, and the memory you leave there (a photo, a video, a few words) seals the card. At the end of the three weeks, you're left with the album of your twenty-one evenings, photos and videos included.
It's $14.99 paid once, and it opens on both your phones from a link, with nothing to install: you buy it, pick the first night, and your partner joins from an invite. There's also a version for long-distance couples, where the book has nothing planned.
The trade-off is deliberate: no paper, no Polaroid to stick in, and twenty-one evenings instead of fifty. In return, the date comes back every evening on its own, instead of waiting for someone to remember to take the book off the shelf.
And if you're the one who wants to write the dates, to give them rather than draw them together, the Unveil calendar makes that the gift version: each day can hide a photo or a few words under a golden scratch card they scratch away with a fingertip, all the way to the date you picked. All 31 days are free with photos and words, and around $10 in total opens every format, the scratch card included.
The right pick if you want the book's mechanics without them falling asleep in a drawer: a draw every evening, three weeks in a row, and your photos kept at the end.
3. A 100 Dates scratch poster, the list on your wall
The same silver, turned to face the wall. Gift Republic's 100 Dates Bucket List Scratch Poster lines up a hundred scratch-off squares, one date idea each, for $20.48 on Amazon, with 4.3 out of 5 across 2,461 ratings. Enno Vatti's version runs from lazy nights in to once-in-a-lifetime plans, for $22, at 4.4 out of 5 across 2,023 ratings. You hang it in the bedroom or the hallway, and your plans stay in plain sight, which a book tucked in a drawer never manages.
The rule flips, though: on these bucket list posters, the activity is there to read from the start, and you scratch its square once you've lived it. You lose the surprise, you gain the choice, and a poster that fills in as you go.
The right pick if you like watching your list fill in on the wall, and choosing Saturday's date together is half the fun.
4. The date jar, homemade
The version that costs almost nothing, and probably the most faithful to the spirit of the book. A jar, folded slips of paper, one idea per slip: you write them together one evening, and the book's rule becomes yours, you draw, you don't put it back. To bring back the money guide, use colored paper. Somewhat Simple sorts its jar into three colors: gray for $10 and under, pink for $10 to $25, red for $25 to $50 and a little planning. When the night comes, you pick the color, never the slip.
To get it started, a dozen ideas in the Adventure Challenge spirit, sorted by color, to rewrite in your own image rather than anyone else's:
- Gray: a picnic on the living room floor, the songs you both played on repeat at nineteen, a sunrise from the hood of the car, a phone-free walk through a neighborhood you've never set foot in, the first movie you ever watched together.
- Pink: the farmers market on a Saturday morning, where each of you shops for the other's dinner, a round of mini golf, ice cream eaten in the cold, a dish from a country neither of you has been to.
- Red: tickets to see a band you've never heard of, a drop-in class in something neither of you knows how to do, a drive to a town an hour away where you've planned nothing at all.
If you'd rather not write a thing, MSEHKM's jar comes already filled with 100 ideas for $13.99, color-coded by mood rather than budget (staying in, day out, night out, romantic).
The jar has its loyal fans. One couple on Reddit picked their most recent date from their "date jar", adding, "We've been together for nearly 23 years." Another admits they never used theirs, "but the night we made the jar was a fun night together!" That may be its best argument: writing the ideas is already a date.
The right pick if money is tight, you like making things, and you want ideas that sound like the two of you rather than challenges written for anyone.
5. Online date night generators
For tonight, without buying or writing anything. A generator draws the idea for you, and that's already half the book. Flamme's is free and deals from 35 hand-written date plans, which you can filter by where (at home, out, or long-distance), by budget and by vibe. Romanceer's, also free, has no filters but a bigger hat, "roughly 500" ideas.
For a deeper pool, the Lovewick app keeps more than 750 free date ideas, filtered by budget, time or distance, and it's one of the apps like Paired we compared. What no generator does is keep a trace: once the idea is drawn, all that's left of the evening is what you make of it.
The right pick if it's for tonight, you have nothing planned, and you just want someone else to decide.
6. The 30-day couple challenge, the free list
A list rather than a book, and it costs nothing. We put together a 30-day couple challenge, one idea a night: tender ones, ones that end in laughter (including a dinner cooked blindfolded while the other guides by voice, a cousin of the book's apple pie), ones that take a little nerve, and six that hold up at five hundred miles. To keep the book's surprise, one of you copies them onto folded slips, and the other only ever discovers the day's.
It's a list to pick from, not a path: no draw, no album at the end, just thirty ideas that cost next to nothing and almost all happen at home, in whatever order you like.
The right pick if you want to start tonight, for free, with challenges that fit between dinner and bedtime.
Couples Edition, Volume 2 or …In Bed
If it's the book itself that tempts you, it comes in several editions, and they aren't made for the same night.
| Couples Edition | Volume 2 | …In Bed | Couples Edition Luxe | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Scratch-off dates | 50 | 30 | 50 | 30 |
| Made for | Every couple, from first dates to 50th anniversaries | Couples who finished the first | Spicier nights, for the bedroom | A keepsake, with questions after every date |
| Price (brand's US site) | $49.99 | $29.99, down from $49.99 | $29.99, down from $49.99 | $79.99 |
The Couples Edition is still the way in, the one the brand says is for you whether you've just started dating or you're celebrating your 50th anniversary. Volume 2 is its sequel, "inspired by five years of real customers' feedback," with thirty all-new challenges. …In Bed keeps the same rule for more intimate evenings, and the Luxe edition, at $79.99, trades quantity for keepsake: thirty dates, connection questions after each one, and extra room to journal. The instant camera only comes in a bundle, $99.99 with the Couples Edition, down from $209.99. Whichever you pick, a scratched challenge gets done, and the time and the budget are still yours to plan.
Adventure Challenge Alternatives at a Glance
| Price | What stays hidden | Long distance | What you keep at the end | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| The Adventure Challenge | $49.99 on the brand's site | The challenge, until you scratch it | No | An album of stuck-in photos |
| Scratch-off date cards | $16.95 to $16.99, $45.99 for The Date Night Book | The date, until you scratch it | No | The scratched cards, or a keepsake book |
| 21 Challenges for Two | $14.99, once | The evening's two challenges | Yes, with its long-distance version | The album of your 21 evenings, photos and videos |
| 100 Dates scratch posters | $20.48 to $22 | Nothing, you scratch after the date | No | A poster on the wall |
| Homemade date jar | The price of the paper, or $13.99 ready-made | The slip you draw | Over video, one of you draws for both | The slips, if you keep them |
| Online generators | Free | The idea drawn | Yes, with Flamme's filter | Nothing |
| 30-day couple challenge | Free | What one of you copies out for the other | Six challenges out of thirty | Whatever you photograph |
Prices checked in October 2026 on each brand's store and on Amazon.com.
How to Choose
It all depends on what drew you to the book in the first place. If it's the object, the paper you'll leaf through ten years from now with the photos stuck inside, get it, straight from the brand's site, or give its closest clone, The Date Night Book, with ten more dates inside. If it's the surprise and the promise not to back out, a jar and a few folded slips do just as much, for the price of an evening spent writing them.
If you live far apart, no book will cross the miles for you: pick from our 51 long-distance date ideas instead. And if it's talking you miss more than going out, games like We're Not Really Strangers put the questions on cards.
The book from Redding got one thing right that goes beyond every format: what brings you closer isn't where you go, it's having said yes before you knew where. All that's left is choosing the shape that will get you to say yes more than three times.
twenty-one evenings left to chance, and the album at the end
21 Challenges for Two
Twenty-one evenings already written, to open one at a time. What you make of them stays inside.
The fear, named
Each of you confides one thing that scares you about the five years ahead. Tonight you only listen, no reassuring, no trying to fix anything: being heard is enough.
The lullaby
Each of you finds the song or lullaby you were sung as a child and plays it for the other. If memory fails, call whoever still remembers, and the phone call will make one more person happy.
Challenge done? Keep a trace of it.
- The drawEach evening offers two, never of the same kind.
- The choiceYou take the one that fits you that evening, the other stays folded away.
- The traceA photo, a word, and the square seals on your evening.
On the last evening, it is no longer a calendar of challenges. It is the album of the three weeks you have just lived.
Premium includedevery format ·password ·nine themes
$14.99one time
The calendar is yours to keep. No subscription.
Secure payment ·Opens right after payment ·14 days to change your mind
One day you'll come across the photo of an evening you never would have chosen, a pie gone wrong, a lake far too cold, a fit of laughter in a car parked in the middle of nowhere. That night, it won't be chance that brought you closer, it will be having agreed to follow it together.